There was a picture of a hot girl with tattoos on the cover of the NY Times magazine yesterday, and it messed with my whole morning. It’s a good rule of thumb never to start the paper by reading the magazine, especially the cover story. The Sunday magazine is best kept until the week, for public transportation or the gym, the only part of the paper that can be saved and not hang over your head like homework. But read the magazine first, and already a half an hour of precious Sunday morning time has passed, and you’re still stuck there with a stack of unread newspaper.
But with the girl and headline, “Blog-Post Confidential: What I gained–and lost–by revealing my intimate life on the web,” I dug right in. I was hoping to find answers to why people, including me, blog about personal issues, and maybe to find the line that separates sharing from oversharing. Also, I was curious about a first person essay as the cover story. I still can’t believe so much space is given to a topic that seems more fitting to the Style section and a Modern Love column.
So anyways, the author Emily made her entrance into the online world with a personal blog called Emily Magazine. She still writes on it, and it is apparent that her Times piece drove traffic and two hundred plus comments to her recent post, “Room-elephant acknowledged.” Her personal blog appears no different from other personal blogs, like mine, except that she seems to have more friends than me, counting about 200 visitors. I have so few visitors, I know them all by name and don’t bother with numbers.
Emily writes that she always desired to broadcast herself, tell others the ongoing story of her life. She says blogging is like a drug, but then excuses her use of the universal metaphor by saying it’s so exact, “maybe it’s not a metaphor at all.” She creates a larger context for the culture of personal blogging by tying it to a time when reality TV rules the airwaves.
The essay is a good read for the voyeuristic, but only an okay read in terms of her insights. To stick with her drug metaphor that is too true to be a metaphor, she should probably just go to blogging rehab, share in group therapy that “The will to blog is a complicated thing, somewhere between inspiration and compulsion.”
Basically, Emily had a personal blog, then a job at Gawker, blogging about “Manhattan media gossip.” She becomes somewhat of a virtual celebrity, equally praised and pissed upon, in the same way that Sex and the City’s Carrie would be, had she blogged for a major New York website. The commenting, not to mention the high-stress life of a blogger (see recent Times article, In the Web World of 24/7 Stress, Writers Blog Till They Drop), as well as the working from home leads to depression.
The question of how personal to be on her Gawker blog (the more personal, the greater the readership it seems) resulted in more personal posts. Then there was a break-up, sex with a co-worker, pseudonyms, a new personal anonymous blog “Heartbreak Soup” that didn’t stay anonymous, password protections, a pay-back, an embarrassing experience with Jimmy Kimmel on TV, and what Emily seems to understand now, as a whole lot of oversharing. She is left with the realization that the only way to eliminate it all is to “destroy the entire Internet.”
But she can’t, so she keeps all her posts up, “as a sort of memorial to a time in my life when I thought my discoveries about myself and what I loved were special enough to merit sharing with the world immediately.” In the end, by writing the Times piece, she is revealing even more about what happened. And to that, she responds, “Well, I’m an oversharer.”
I’m still not positive what I walked away learning, or thinking more about after reading this story of a blogger’s life unraveling. (I particularly like the one sentence she slipped in about the major changes leading to the upswing in her life, including, “I quit smoking pot cold turkey.” Clearly, nobody told her that pot leads to oversharing on a grand scale.)
Yes, the Interwebs is a dangerous place, but I already knew this. We all have it in us to be Google-stalkers. Recently, I’ve heard quite a few confessions regarding the post-breakup online stalking, which basically ranges from checking MySpace and Facebook pages of exes to communities where they post messages to searching Craigslist personals for terms that will lead to the ex’s ad. This is self-torture, but it is surprisingly common.
As someone with the genetics, or maybe it’s the compulsion to share the ongoing story of my life, I relate very much to those who cannot help but start blogs and continue to unburden themselves while lying in unmade beds. To all the of the people who feel a twinge of nervousness as the mouse arrow rests on the “Publish” button, to all of us out there with the blogging disease, I say, Let us overshare. Let us overshare with restraint.